Updated November 2026

Choosing puppy crate training toys can feel confusing, because the shelves are full of products that all claim to calm a new puppy. Most of them fall into a few groups: lick mats that keep a pup busy, treat dispensers that reward quiet time, heartbeat plushes that mimic a littermate, and freezable toys that soothe sore gums. This list covers seven options across those groups. Our selection method was research-based: we looked at manufacturer specifications, brand reputation and the patterns owners commonly report about durability, cleaning and how well a toy holds a puppy’s attention in a crate.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1SPOT Soothers Multipurpose Dog Lick MatTOP CHOICEBest overallSPOT Soothers Multipurpose Dog Lick MatView on Amazon
  2. 2Interactive Dog Toys Crate Training Aids for PuppiesTOP CHOICEBest for busy treat timeInteractive Dog Toys Crate Training Aids for PuppiesView on Amazon
  3. 3Puppy Teething Toys Peanut Butter Dispenser (Blue)TOP CHOICEBest for teething pupsPuppy Teething Toys Peanut Butter Dispenser (Blue)View on Amazon
  4. 4Snuggle Puppy Junior Heartbeat Toy (Biscuit)Best for small breedsSnuggle Puppy Junior Heartbeat Toy (Biscuit)View on Amazon
  5. 5Heartbeat Puppy Toy for Anxiety Relief (Pink)Best budget pickHeartbeat Puppy Toy for Anxiety Relief (Pink)View on Amazon
  6. 6PetSafe Chilly Penguin Freezable Treat Holding Dog Toy (Small)Best freezable optionPetSafe Chilly Penguin Freezable Treat Holding Dog Toy (Small)View on Amazon
  7. 7Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Toy (Breed Buddies Bully Breed)Best for bully breedsSnuggle Puppy Heartbeat Toy (Breed Buddies Bully Breed)View on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product Best for Key feature
SPOT Soothers Multipurpose Dog Lick Mat Overall use and slow licking Food-grade rubber, dishwasher safe
Interactive Dog Toys Crate Training Aids (peanut butter dispenser) Busy treat time Dispenses food to occupy a puppy
Puppy Teething Toys Peanut Butter Dispenser (blue) Teething pups Textured design for chewing and licking
Snuggle Puppy Junior Heartbeat Toy (Biscuit) Small breeds under 25 lbs Heartbeat plush with a warming pack
Heartbeat Puppy Toy (pink) Budget-conscious owners Heartbeat plush for comfort
PetSafe Chilly Penguin Freezable Toy (Small) Teething and cooling Freezable, stackable, vanilla-scented
Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Toy (Bully Breed) Bully breeds and sturdy comfort Heartbeat plush sized for bully breeds

SPOT Soothers Multipurpose Dog Lick Mat

SPOT Soothers Multipurpose Dog Lick Mat - 6in Slow Feeder & Crate Enrichment Toy for Small & Medium Dogs and Puppies, Food-Grade Rubber, Dishwasher Safe, Anxiety & Boredom Relief

SPOT Soothers Multipurpose Dog Lick Mat – 6in Slow Feeder & Crate Enrichment Toy for Small & Medium Dogs and Puppies, Food-Grade Rubber, Dishwasher Safe, Anxiety & Boredom Relief

View on Amazon

Best for: Slow, calming licking inside the crate

This lick mat suits owners who want one versatile toy for crate time, meal time and winding down. Its 6-inch size is aimed at small and medium dogs and puppies, which makes it easy to fit in a standard crate tray.

Key specs

  • 6-inch mat size (per listing)
  • Made from food-grade rubber (per listing)
  • Dishwasher safe (per listing)

Pros

  • Easy to clean after messy use
  • Slows eating and licking, which helps occupy a puppy
  • Works for both meals and crate enrichment

Cons

  • Small size may not satisfy large or very active puppies
  • Needs supervision with soft spread foods to avoid frustration

Bottom line: A strong first purchase for owners of small or medium puppies who want a flexible, easy-to-clean option.

View on Amazon

Interactive Dog Toys Crate Training Aids for Puppies

Interactive Dog Toys, Crate Training Aids for Puppies, Reduce Stress Anxiety Peanut Butter Dog Food Treat Dispenser Toys

Interactive Dog Toys, Crate Training Aids for Puppies, Reduce Stress Anxiety Peanut Butter Dog Food Treat Dispenser Toys

View on Amazon

Best for: Keeping a puppy busy during calm crate time

This peanut butter treat dispenser is designed for owners who want a puppy to work for food while settling. It works best when you fill it lightly at first so the puppy can succeed.

Key specs

  • Treat dispenser design for peanut butter or soft food (per listing)
  • Marketed as a crate training aid for puppies (per listing)

Pros

  • Gives a puppy a task that takes focus away from whining
  • Simple to fill and rinse
  • Useful for teaching a puppy to settle alone

Cons

  • Can get messy with sticky spreads
  • Owners report that very determined chewers may need supervision

Bottom line: Good for owners who want a food-based puzzle to pair with crate sessions, especially during the first weeks.

View on Amazon

Puppy Teething Toys Peanut Butter Dispenser (Blue)

Puppy Teething Toys,Peanut Butter Dog Food Treat Dispenser Toys Interactive Dog Toys,Crate Training Aids for Puppies,Blue

Puppy Teething Toys,Peanut Butter Dog Food Treat Dispenser Toys Interactive Dog Toys,Crate Training Aids for Puppies,Blue

View on Amazon

Best for: Puppies chewing and licking during teething

Teething often makes puppies want to chew everything, including crate bars and bedding. A textured dispenser that accepts soft treats gives the puppy an approved outlet for that urge.

Key specs

  • Peanut butter and soft food dispensing design (per listing)
  • Blue color option (per listing)

Pros

  • Redirects chewing away from furniture and crate parts
  • Textured surface can soothe sore gums
  • Provides a rewarding activity during crate time

Cons

  • Requires regular cleaning to prevent residue buildup
  • Not a substitute for a supervised chew toy for heavy chewers

Bottom line: A practical pick for teething puppies who need something to chew while confined.

View on Amazon

Snuggle Puppy Junior Heartbeat Toy (Biscuit)

Calming heartbeat toy, crate training, heat pack, new puppy essentials, first nights, sleep, small breeds under 25 lbs Snuggle Puppy Junior Heartbeat Toy, Calming Comfort, Small Breeds - Biscuit

Calming heartbeat toy, crate training, heat pack, new puppy essentials, first nights, sleep, small breeds under 25 lbs Snuggle Puppy Junior Heartbeat Toy, Calming Comfort, Small Breeds – Biscuit

View on Amazon

Best for: Small breeds settling into a crate for the first nights

Heartbeat plush toys are built to mimic the rhythm of a littermate’s heartbeat, a feature many owners associate with easier first nights. This junior version is sized for small breeds under 25 lbs.

Key specs

  • Designed for small breeds under 25 lbs (per listing)
  • Heartbeat feature for calming comfort (per listing)

Pros

  • Sized appropriately for small puppies
  • Offers a familiar comfort object for crate sleep
  • Easy to bring along during the transition to a new home

Cons

  • Not suitable for larger puppies who may tear it apart
  • Owners report that the plush needs supervision with unsupervised chewers

Bottom line: Best suited to owners of small-breed puppies who want a soft, calming companion for crate nights.

View on Amazon

Heartbeat Puppy Toy for Anxiety Relief (Pink)

Heartbeat Puppy Toy Dog Heartbeat Toy for Anxiety Relief and Calming Aid, Heartbeat Stuffed Animal for Comfort Sleep Aid Crate Training Cuddle, Pink

Heartbeat Puppy Toy Dog Heartbeat Toy for Anxiety Relief and Calming Aid, Heartbeat Stuffed Animal for Comfort Sleep Aid Crate Training Cuddle, Pink

View on Amazon

Best for: A budget-friendly comfort toy for crate sleep

This heartbeat plush is aimed at owners who want the comfort-object approach without a premium price tag. It is marketed for anxiety relief, comfort and crate training.

Key specs

  • Heartbeat plush design (per listing)
  • Pink color option (per listing)

Pros

  • Accessible option for trying a heartbeat toy
  • Soft, huggable size for comfort during sleep
  • Can help a puppy feel less alone at night

Cons

  • Owners often report that plush seams need checking regularly
  • Not designed for heavy chewing

Bottom line: A sensible budget choice for owners who want to test whether a heartbeat toy helps their puppy settle.

View on Amazon

PetSafe Chilly Penguin Freezable Treat Holding Dog Toy (Small)

Fill with Frozen Treats Like Peanut Butter or Wet Dog Food, Vanilla-Scented and Stackable Design, Top-Shelf Dishwasher Safe PetSafe Chilly Penguin Freezable Treat Holding Dog Toy, Small

Fill with Frozen Treats Like Peanut Butter or Wet Dog Food, Vanilla-Scented and Stackable Design, Top-Shelf Dishwasher Safe PetSafe Chilly Penguin Freezable Treat Holding Dog Toy, Small

View on Amazon

Best for: Teething puppies who benefit from cold relief

The Chilly Penguin is a freezable toy you fill with treats or wet food and freeze. Manufacturers specify that it is vanilla-scented, stackable and dishwasher safe, which makes it easy to rotate.

Key specs

  • Freezable design for peanut butter or wet food (per listing)
  • Vanilla-scented and stackable (per listing)
  • Dishwasher safe (per listing)

Pros

  • Cold texture can soothe sore gums during teething
  • Lasts longer than a simple treat for crate time
  • Easy to clean and rotate

Cons

  • Must be frozen ahead of time, which requires planning
  • Small size may be too small for larger puppies

Bottom line: A good choice for teething small puppies if you plan ahead and keep a few frozen rotations ready.

View on Amazon

Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Toy (Breed Buddies Bully Breed)

Crate training comfort, heat pack, new puppy essentials, first nights sleep, Pit Bull, Bulldog Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Toy, Calming Comfort, Breed Buddies Bully Breed

Crate training comfort, heat pack, new puppy essentials, first nights sleep, Pit Bull, Bulldog Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Toy, Calming Comfort, Breed Buddies Bully Breed

View on Amazon

Best for: Bully breed puppies needing a sturdier comfort toy

This heartbeat plush is sized for bully breeds and is marketed for crate comfort and first nights at home. Owners of larger, more robust puppies often look for a plush that holds up better than standard sizes.

Key specs

  • Designed for bully breeds (per listing)
  • Heartbeat feature for calming comfort (per listing)

Pros

  • Sized for larger puppies that outgrow junior versions
  • Provides a familiar comfort object for crate sleep
  • Pairs well with a warming routine during the first nights

Cons

  • Larger size takes up more space in a small crate
  • Still requires supervision with determined chewers

Bottom line: The right pick for bully breed owners who want a larger heartbeat companion for crate nights.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Safety and materials

Look for toys made from food-grade rubber or other materials the manufacturer describes as safe for chewing. Check seams, eyes and stuffing on plush toys, and remove any toy that starts to shed parts. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission publishes general guidance on pet product and toy safety that is worth reviewing before you buy.

Good picks for this: SPOT Soothers Multipurpose Dog Lick Mat, PetSafe Chilly Penguin Freezable Treat Holding Dog Toy

Size and fit for your puppy

A toy should fit comfortably in the crate without taking up so much room that the puppy cannot turn around or lie down. Match the size to your puppy’s expected adult weight range where possible, since a toy that is too small can become a swallowing hazard for a bigger puppy.

Good picks for this: Snuggle Puppy Junior Heartbeat Toy, Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Toy (Bully Breed)

Treat-dispensing design

Treat dispensers keep a puppy occupied, but the difficulty matters. Start with a loose fill and easy access, then make the puzzle slightly harder as your puppy learns. Overly difficult toys can frustrate a young pup and encourage whining.

Good picks for this: Interactive Dog Toys Crate Training Aids for Puppies, Puppy Teething Toys Peanut Butter Dispenser

Teething support

Teething puppies often need something cold or textured to chew. Freezable toys can help with sore gums, but only offer them under supervision and remove any pieces that soften or break. Rotate toys so the puppy does not lose interest.

Good picks for this: PetSafe Chilly Penguin Freezable Treat Holding Dog Toy, Puppy Teething Toys Peanut Butter Dispenser

Comfort and heartbeat toys

Heartbeat plush toys are marketed to help puppies settle, particularly during the first nights away from littermates. Results vary from puppy to puppy, so pair the toy with a consistent bedtime routine rather than relying on it alone.

Good picks for this: Heartbeat Puppy Toy for Anxiety Relief, Snuggle Puppy Junior Heartbeat Toy

Cleaning and durability

Dishwasher-safe toys are easier to keep hygienic, which matters because food residue can attract bacteria. Check the cleaning instructions, inspect toys weekly for wear, and replace anything with cracks, tears or loose parts.

Good picks for this: SPOT Soothers Multipurpose Dog Lick Mat, PetSafe Chilly Penguin Freezable Treat Holding Dog Toy

Your puppy’s breed and size

Breed size and chewing strength shape which toy will last. Small breeds usually do well with junior-sized plush and small dispensers, while bully breeds and larger puppies often need sturdier, larger designs. Consider how your puppy handles other toys before choosing.

Good picks for this: Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Toy (Bully Breed), Snuggle Puppy Junior Heartbeat Toy

FAQ

Are puppy crate training toys necessary?

No. Many puppies settle well with a crate, a blanket and a consistent routine alone. Toys can add enrichment and make crate time more rewarding, especially during the first weeks, but they are a helpful tool rather than a requirement.

When should I introduce a toy into the crate?

Many trainers suggest introducing a toy once the puppy is comfortable entering and resting in the crate. Start with a lightly filled or simple toy, and watch for any signs of anxiety before leaving it in for longer periods.

Can a puppy choke on a crate toy?

Yes, any toy can pose a choking risk if a puppy chews off and swallows small pieces. Supervise new toys, choose sizes appropriate for your puppy, and remove any toy that breaks or shows loose parts. Consult a veterinarian if your puppy swallows anything unusual.

Should I leave a treat dispenser in the crate overnight?

Many owners prefer to offer treat dispensers during short daytime crate sessions rather than overnight, since overnight use can lead to late-night chewing or mess. Your veterinarian or a certified trainer can help you decide what works for your puppy.

How often should I clean crate toys?

Wash lick mats and treat dispensers after each use, or at least daily if they are used at meals. Plush toys should be checked for damage weekly and cleaned according to the manufacturer’s instructions.

What if my puppy ignores the toy?

Some puppies take time to warm up to a new toy. Try a different texture or fill, offer the toy while you are nearby, and keep sessions short. If your puppy shows persistent distress in the crate, consult a professional trainer or veterinarian.

Conclusion

For most new owners, a lick mat or treat dispenser is the most versatile starting point because it works for meals, crate time and settling. Teething puppies often do best with freezable or textured options, while small-breed and bully-breed owners may prefer heartbeat plush toys sized to their puppy. Choose based on your puppy’s age, size and chewing habits, supervise new toys, and remember that a steady routine matters more than any single product. For more on building a crate routine, see Crate Training a Puppy Overnight: A Step-by-Step Guide and Dog Toys for Crate Training: Choosing and Using Them Right.

Sources

Caleb Morgan

About Caleb Morgan

Caleb Morgan is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our dogs & puppies guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.