Updated November 2026

A dog playpen with tray makes puppy setup easier because the tray catches accidents, protects floors and keeps bedding dry. This list compares seven products by how well they match common needs: pad fit, washability, pen size, portability and how simple they are to clean. Selection was based on product listings, brand reputation and patterns in owner feedback, not hands-on testing.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Midwest Homes for Pets Puppy Playpen Replacement TrayTOP CHOICEBest overallMidwest Homes for Pets Puppy Playpen Replacement TrayView on Amazon
  2. 2Drymate Jumbo Dog Playpen MatTOP CHOICEBest for washable accidentsDrymate Jumbo Dog Playpen MatView on Amazon
  3. 3Silicone Dog Crate Mat 36" x 24"TOP CHOICEBest for silicone cleanupSilicone Dog Crate Mat 36" x 24"View on Amazon
  4. 4Dog Playpen Bottom Pad 36 Inch 4 PanelsBest for 36-inch pensDog Playpen Bottom Pad 36 Inch 4 PanelsView on Amazon
  5. 5Playpen Bottom Pad 24'' Width 8 PanelBest for small 8-panel pensPlaypen Bottom Pad 24'' Width 8 PanelView on Amazon
  6. 6Thick Super Absorbent Dog Pads for Puppy PlaypenBest for extra absorbencyThick Super Absorbent Dog Pads for Puppy PlaypenView on Amazon
  7. 742x42 Inches Puppy Playpen with Gate, Dog Playpen for Puppies or SmallBest for a full pen with gate42×42 Inches Puppy Playpen with Gate, Dog Playpen for Puppies or SmallView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Product Best for Key feature
Midwest Homes for Pets Puppy Playpen Replacement Tray Midwest pen owners Direct fit for models 236-05 and 236-10
Drymate Jumbo Dog Playpen Mat Washable accident control Waterproof, slip-resistant, machine washable
Silicone Dog Crate Mat 36″ x 24″ Easy cleanup Raised edge, leakproof silicone
Dog Playpen Bottom Pad 36 Inch 4 Panels 36-inch four-panel pens Hoop and loop attachment
Playpen Bottom Pad 24” Width 8 Panel Small 8-panel pens Hook connect, easy to move
Thick Super Absorbent Dog Pads for Puppy Playpen Heavy leakers Thick absorbent layers, two-pack
DogFence 42×42 Puppy Playpen with Gate Full pen setups Gate and high-strength mesh

Midwest Homes for Pets Puppy Playpen Replacement Tray

MidWest Homes for Pets Puppy Playpen Replacement Tray for Midwest Puppy Playpen Models 236-05 & 236-10

MidWest Homes for Pets Puppy Playpen Replacement Tray for Midwest Puppy Playpen Models 236-05 & 236-10

View on Amazon

Best for: Owners who already have a Midwest puppy pen and need a matching tray.

This tray is designed to replace the floor tray for specific Midwest puppy playpen models. It suits owners who want an exact fit rather than a universal pad.

Pros

  • Manufacturer lists fit for models 236-05 and 236-10
  • Simple swap for worn-out trays

Cons

  • Only fits compatible Midwest models

View on Amazon

Drymate Jumbo Dog Playpen Mat

DrymateSuper Absorbent, Waterproof, Slip-Resistant, Machine Wash, Reusable Puppy Pads for Training, Whelping, Incontinence, USA Made Jumbo Dog Playpen Mat, Washable Pee Pads For Dogs, 60x74, 1-Pack

DrymateSuper Absorbent, Waterproof, Slip-Resistant, Machine Wash, Reusable Puppy Pads for Training, Whelping, Incontinence, USA Made Jumbo Dog Playpen Mat, Washable Pee Pads For Dogs, 60×74, 1-Pack

View on Amazon

Best for: Washable, reusable protection for frequent accidents.

Suited to owners who want a mat they can launder rather than throw away after every mess, especially during housetraining.

Pros

  • Listed as waterproof and slip-resistant
  • Machine washable and reusable

Cons

  • Needs regular washing to stay effective

View on Amazon

Silicone Dog Crate Mat 36″ x 24″

Dog Cage Mat with Raised Edge, Washable, Non-Slip, Leakproof Kennel Mat for Protect Floors, Reusable Dog Playpen Mat Silicone Dog Crate Mat 36" x 24" Extra Large Pet Bed Mat

Dog Cage Mat with Raised Edge, Washable, Non-Slip, Leakproof Kennel Mat for Protect Floors, Reusable Dog Playpen Mat Silicone Dog Crate Mat 36" x 24" Extra Large Pet Bed Mat

View on Amazon

Best for: Quick wipe-down cleanup and floor protection.

A good fit for owners who prefer a hard, wipeable surface over fabric and want a raised edge to contain spills.

Pros

  • Raised edge helps hold liquid
  • Wipes clean without a washing machine

Cons

  • Less cushioned than a fabric pad

View on Amazon

Dog Playpen Bottom Pad 36 Inch 4 Panels

Dog Playpen Bottom Pad Fits for 36 Inch 4 Panels Exercise Pet Playpen, Dog Crate Pad Puppy Playpen Pad, Hoop and Loop Design (Note: Playpen Not Included). -Black

Dog Playpen Bottom Pad Fits for 36 Inch 4 Panels Exercise Pet Playpen, Dog Crate Pad Puppy Playpen Pad, Hoop and Loop Design (Note: Playpen Not Included). -Black

View on Amazon

Best for: Four-panel pens around 36 inches across.

This pad is sold as a bottom liner for a 36-inch pen and is best for owners whose pen dimensions match the listing.

Pros

  • Hoop and loop design for securing the pad
  • Listed size fits 36-inch four-panel pens

Cons

  • Playpen not included

View on Amazon

Playpen Bottom Pad 24” Width 8 Panel

Use as Top, Protect Floor, Easy to Move and Clean – Suitable for Puppy, Duck, and Other Small Animals. Playpen Bottom Pad for 24'' Width 8 Panel Pen, Hook Connect, Black

Use as Top, Protect Floor, Easy to Move and Clean – Suitable for Puppy, Duck, and Other Small Animals. Playpen Bottom Pad for 24'' Width 8 Panel Pen, Hook Connect, Black

View on Amazon

Best for: Smaller eight-panel pens with a 24-inch width.

Works for small pets and compact pens. It is also sold as a top cover, so check the listing before ordering.

Pros

  • Hook connect design
  • Easy to lift out and clean

Cons

  • Only suits the listed 24-inch width

View on Amazon

Thick Super Absorbent Dog Pads for Puppy Playpen

Thick Super Absorbent, Leak-Proof & Non-Slip, Waterproof Dog Pads for Puppy Playpen, Crate, Whelping Box, Potty Training Grey Washable Pee Pads for Dogs, Reusable Puppy Pads for Dog Playpen 2PC

Thick Super Absorbent, Leak-Proof & Non-Slip, Waterproof Dog Pads for Puppy Playpen, Crate, Whelping Box, Potty Training Grey Washable Pee Pads for Dogs, Reusable Puppy Pads for Dog Playpen 2PC

View on Amazon

Best for: Heavy leakers and puppies still learning bladder control.

Useful for owners who need extra absorbency and a two-pack to rotate while one is in the wash.

Pros

  • Thick absorbent layers listed
  • Non-slip backing and two pads included

Cons

  • Thicker pads may need more laundry space

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Pen Size and Tray Fit

Measure your playpen panels before buying a tray or pad. A tray or mat sized for a 24-inch, 8-panel pen will not fit a 36-inch, 4-panel pen, so match the dimensions to your setup. A snug fit keeps the tray from sliding and prevents leaks from running underneath.

Check whether the product is a replacement tray made for a specific model or a universal mat. Brand-specific trays usually fit better, while universal mats give you more flexibility if you change playpens later.

Waterproof Backing and Absorbency

Look for a waterproof or leakproof bottom layer so urine does not seep into your floor or carpet. The absorbent top layer should pull moisture away from your puppy’s paws so the surface stays drier.

Silicone and rubber-backed mats resist liquid well but may not absorb much on their own. Pads with multiple layers tend to handle heavier accidents better.

Washability and Reusability

If you plan to use a tray through potty training, choose a product labeled machine washable and reusable. Washable pads cost less over time than disposable options and reduce waste.

Check the care instructions for heat and drying limits. Some materials hold up well through frequent washing, while others may lose absorbency or grip after many cycles.

Slip Resistance and Stability

A non-slip bottom keeps the tray from shifting when your puppy pushes against the walls or plays inside the pen. This matters most on hard floors, where a sliding pad can bunch up or leave gaps.

Raised edges or hook-and-loop fasteners can also help hold the tray in place and keep liquid from spreading beyond the pad.

Portability and Use Case

Think about where the playpen will be used. Lightweight, easy-to-fold mats suit owners who move the pen between rooms or take it outdoors, while heavier-duty trays work well for a permanent indoor spot.

If you need a tray for whelping, crate training or small animals as well as puppies, choose a size and material flexible enough for those uses.

FAQ

Do I need a tray if my puppy is already house trained?

Not always, but a tray can still help with occasional accidents, travel and older dogs with bladder issues. It also protects the floor under the playpen from spills, drool and shedding. Many owners keep one in place even after training is complete.

Can I use a regular towel instead of a playpen tray?

A towel can absorb some moisture, but it usually slides, bunches and soaks through quickly. A pad designed for playpens has a waterproof backing and fits the pen more securely. Towels are better as a temporary solution than a long-term one.

How often should I wash a washable playpen pad?

Wash it after any significant accident and clean it regularly, especially during potty training when it may get used several times a day. Check for odor or staining, since residue can encourage a puppy to return to the same spot. Always follow the manufacturer’s care instructions.

Will a tray fit any brand of playpen?

Not necessarily. Brand-specific replacement trays are sized for particular models, while universal mats are cut to standard dimensions that may not match every frame. Measure your pen’s interior floor space and compare it to the product size before buying.

Are silicone mats safe for puppies to chew on?

Silicone is generally durable, but a puppy that chews may still tear or damage edges and fasteners. Supervise your dog during play and remove any mat with torn or loose parts. If your puppy is a heavy chewer, choose a sturdier option and check it often.

Conclusion

Owners who already have a specific playpen model should choose a replacement tray made for that frame, since the fit will be most reliable. Those who want a flexible option that works with different pen sizes or who plan to use the pad for crates and other setups should consider a universal washable mat.

For frequent accidents during potty training, prioritize washability and waterproof backing. For smaller puppies or a simple setup, a lightweight, non-slip pad with a secure fit is often the most practical choice.

Owen Palmer

About Owen Palmer

Owen Palmer is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our dogs & puppies guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.