Updated November 2026
If you are crate training a dog during the day, the goal is usually simple: a calm, comfortable crate that your dog accepts while you are at work, running errands or busy around the house. Books and training plans can help a great deal here, because a clear daily structure is often what separates a dog who settles from one who whines and paces. The three picks below were chosen by looking at the stated focus of each guide, the level of detail it offers, whether it fits a particular living situation, and the patterns owners commonly describe in reviews. None of them was tested or used by our editors, so treat the descriptions as a summary of what the listings say rather than a hands-on verdict.
Our top picks at a glance
- 1
TOP CHOICEBest overallCrate Training a Puppy or DogView on Amazon - 2
Best for small apartmentsApartment Puppy Crate Training: A 21-Day PlanView on Amazon - 3
Best for owners who want broad puppy guidanceThe Only Positive Puppy Training Book You'll Ever NeedView on Amazon
Our Top Picks
| Product | Best for | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| Crate Training a Puppy or Dog | First-time owners who want a structured daily routine | Reward-based, step-by-step plan with daily exercises and a training log |
| Apartment Puppy Crate Training: A 21-Day Plan | Owners in condos and small homes | Day-by-day schedule designed around limited space |
| The Only Positive Puppy Training Book You’ll Ever Need | Owners who want crate work alongside potty training and socialization | Broad positive-training guide covering several puppy skills |
Crate Training a Puppy or Dog
Crate Training a Puppy or Dog: A calm, reward-based, step-by-step plan for first-time and everyday owners, with daily exercises and a training log to follow at home
Best for: Owners who want a clear, repeatable routine for crate training a dog during the day
This guide suits first-time owners and anyone who has tried crate training before without a plan. It is built around calm, reward-based steps, so the dog learns that the crate is a pleasant place rather than a punishment. The daily exercises and training log make it easier to see whether your dog is progressing or stalling.
Key specs
- Format: step-by-step plan with daily exercises
- Includes a training log for tracking progress
- Focus: puppies and adult dogs
Pros
- Clear daily structure that is easy to follow
- Reward-based approach that avoids forcing the dog into the crate
- Training log helps you spot problems early
Cons
- Less coverage of housebreaking and socialization than broader guides
- Works best if you can commit to the daily sessions
Bottom line: The best starting point for most owners who want a dependable, day-by-day method for crate training a dog during the day.
Apartment Puppy Crate Training: A 21-Day Plan
Best for: Owners in small spaces who need a crate routine that fits a tight schedule
This plan is aimed at people living in condos, apartments and other compact homes, where a crate may sit in the main living area and noise matters to neighbors. The 21-day structure gives you a defined timeline, which helps when you are trying to fit training around work hours.
Key specs
- Format: 21-day, day-by-day plan
- Focus: puppies in apartments and small spaces
Pros
- Timeline makes progress easy to measure
- Addresses the realities of shared walls and limited floor space
- Short daily steps suit busy schedules
Cons
- Narrower focus than general puppy training guides
- The 21-day pace may feel fast for some puppies, so you may need to repeat stages
Bottom line: A good match for apartment dwellers who want a structured, time-limited method for crate training a dog during the day.
The Only Positive Puppy Training Book You’ll Ever Need
The Only Positive Puppy Training Book You'll Ever Need: A Complete Step-By-Step Guide to Potty Training, Housebreaking, Socializing, and Raising An … Minutes a Day (Positive Dog Training Books)
Best for: Owners who want crate training covered as part of a wider puppy-raising plan
This book covers potty training, housebreaking, socialization and general positive training, with crate work as one piece of the picture. It suits owners who would rather have one reference for the whole first year than separate guides for each skill.
Key specs
- Format: complete positive-training guide
- Covers potty training, housebreaking and socialization
Pros
- Covers several puppy skills in one place
- Positive-training focus is consistent throughout
- Useful reference after the crate-training stage ends
Cons
- Crate training is not the sole focus, so the coverage is less detailed
- Broad scope can make it harder to find a single day-by-day schedule
Bottom line: Best for owners who want a single all-round puppy guide that includes crate training alongside other skills.
Buying Guide
Structure and daily schedule
Look for a guide that gives you a clear sequence of steps rather than general advice. Crate training usually works best when the dog is introduced to the crate in small stages, with short sessions that increase over time. A plan that lays out what to do each day makes it easier to stay consistent, which matters a great deal when you are away for several hours.
Good picks for this: Crate Training a Puppy or Dog, Apartment Puppy Crate Training: A 21-Day Plan
Reward-based methods
Crate training is far more successful when the dog associates the crate with good things such as chews, meals and calm praise. Guides that rely on force or long periods of confinement without preparation tend to produce anxious dogs. Check that the method is described as positive or reward-based.
Good picks for this: Crate Training a Puppy or Dog, The Only Positive Puppy Training Book You’ll Ever Need
Living situation and space
If you live in an apartment or shared building, consider how the crate fits into your home and how much noise your dog may make during training. A guide that addresses small spaces will help you plan the crate’s location and the length of time your dog is alone.
Good picks for this: Apartment Puppy Crate Training: A 21-Day Plan
Puppy versus adult dog
Puppies generally need shorter crate sessions and more frequent bathroom breaks than adult dogs. Confirm whether the guide is written for puppies, adults or both, and adjust the timing to your dog’s age and bladder control.
Good picks for this: Crate Training a Puppy or Dog, The Only Positive Puppy Training Book You’ll Ever Need
Scope beyond the crate
Some owners want a book that covers only crate work, while others prefer guidance on housebreaking, socialization and general behavior. Decide which you need before buying, since a broader guide will cover crate training in less depth.
Good picks for this: The Only Positive Puppy Training Book You’ll Ever Need, Crate Training a Puppy or Dog
Consistency and tracking
Progress in crate training is easier to judge when you record what happened each day, such as how long the dog stayed calm and whether it needed a bathroom break. A guide with a built-in log or tracking method can make this simpler.
Good picks for this: Crate Training a Puppy or Dog, Apartment Puppy Crate Training: A 21-Day Plan
For more background on the process itself, see Crate Training Puppies During the Day: A Step-by-Step Plan and Schedule for Crate Training: A Step-by-Step Daily Plan for Puppies and Dogs. If your dog is anxious when left alone, Crate Training for Anxious Dog: A Step-by-Step Guide That Works covers a gentler pace. Owners who work full days may also find Crate Training a Dog While at Work: A Step-by-Step Guide useful.
FAQ
How long can a dog stay in a crate during the day?
Most puppies cannot hold their bladder for long, so they need frequent breaks. A common general guideline is that a puppy can wait roughly one hour per month of age, up to a practical limit, but this varies by dog. Adult dogs typically tolerate longer periods, though most should not be crated for an entire workday without a break. Speak with your veterinarian about what is appropriate for your dog’s age and health.
How do I start crate training a dog during the day?
Begin with short sessions while you are at home. Place a few treats inside, let your dog enter on its own, and close the door for a few seconds while you stay nearby. Gradually increase the time. The step-by-step guides above lay out this progression in more detail.
Should I crate my dog while I am at work?
Many owners do, but the dog should be introduced to the crate gradually before full workdays begin. Also consider whether a dog-walker or a midday visit could break up the time alone. For more on this, see the guide on crate training during work hours linked above.
What should I put in the crate during the day?
A comfortable bed, a safe chew and water are common choices, though water should be checked for your dog’s age and bladder needs. Avoid loose bedding that could be chewed and swallowed. Puppies may need a smaller space with a divider to prevent soiling.
My dog cries when I leave the crate. What should I do?
Crying is common early on. Avoid letting the dog out while it is whining, since this can teach it that noise gets results. Return to an earlier, shorter step in the plan and reward calm behavior. If the distress is severe or persistent, consult a veterinarian or a certified behavior professional.
Can an adult dog learn crate training during the day?
Yes. Adult dogs can learn crate training, though the process may take longer if the dog has no prior experience. The principles are the same: positive associations, short sessions and gradual increases in time.
Is a crate cruel for a dog left alone during the day?
A crate used properly, with appropriate time limits, water and a comfortable setup, is widely used by owners and trainers. It becomes a problem when the dog is left for too long or is used as punishment. If you have concerns about your dog’s welfare, a veterinarian or professional trainer can help you find a suitable routine.
Conclusion
For most owners, Crate Training a Puppy or Dog is the strongest starting point, thanks to its structured daily steps and reward-based approach. Apartment Puppy Crate Training: A 21-Day Plan suits people working within limited space and a set timeline, while The Only Positive Puppy Training Book You’ll Ever Need is the better choice if you want crate training alongside potty training and socialization. Choose the guide that matches your living situation and the level of detail you need, then stick with a consistent daily routine.
Sources
- General guidance on crate use, housetraining and puppy care (akc.org)
- Position statements and owner resources on animal welfare and confinement (avma.org)
- Safety information on pet products and enclosures (cpsc.gov)
